Number and duration
Jamuna sports made an extreme discrimination in their
show in case of numbering male and female sports news. From 25th September to
28th September, there was not a single sports news on women's. They did not
cover any women's sports news of inside and outside of Bangladesh. A surprising
fact was that Indian women cricket team was having a long tour in Australia but
Jamuna sports did not cover any news of the tour. Analysis says there was total
78 male sports news. Unfortunately, Jamuna sports reported only 8 sports news
for women athletes throughout the 15 days analysis. Male and female mix news
was only 3. The duration was 2 hours 11 minutes for men sports news where women
got the screen only for 16 minutes. Noticeable fact is, that was the time when
women had different games in inside and outside the country, but Jamuna TV was
not interested to cover it.
Scripting
On a comparative result, Jamuna sports had a very few
sports news about women. When competence and completeness came into the news,
men got full of attention and priority from presenter. Their starting could
attract audience easily. On 6th October, BCB had president election. Jamuna
sports prioritise the event from Bangladesh men's cricket perspective. When
Jamuna sports did not have any good contents, they focused on unnecessary men
athletes’ news and presenter presented it in a polished way. On 30th September,
there was a news of Cricketer Nasir Hossain's marital issue. The report was
done in a well-established manner. Only one women's news got best presentation
from presenter which was broadcasted on 9th October. The news was about the
Premier League arrangement of women's cricket where the presenter put his facts
in an impartial way to the audience.
Thematic
Jamuna sports chose mostly unnecessary contents for
men’s sports. But that news was full of details. The reporter covered every
aspect of news. That news had Voice Over, SOT, Voxpop, Interview and other
elements. In case of women's sports only two report got superior coverage. One
was from India vs Aus ODI match where an Indian player was not given out by
umpire but she left the field. The report was basically shown that Women's
cricket is promoting ethics on ground nowadays. It was a good report which
carried every details.
There was a report of 9th October where guest speaker
showed prominence of women's sports. This program was started with this women's
sports news which was quite unusual to watch on TV. The report was for 8
minutes. It was well structured in sentence formatting.
Production quality
Jamuna sports had only 8 special reports on women's
sports. Among this 8 news, only two news got high production quality. Other
three news had poor image for portrayal. They did not use any videography for
covering the news. On 25th September, Bangladesh women's football team had a
match with Nepal Women’s Football team, but Jamuna sports covered this
important news with only some poor images of players.
Headline
Jamuna sports discriminated men's and Women's sports
news on in some of their headlines. When they covered any news of men's
cricket, they did not mention the word men for the news but same did not go for
Women. On 4th October's news, the headline was - Loyalty in women's cricket.
The reporter mentioned the word women for here. When it comes to men, they use
the overall term Cricket / Football team.
Sports journalist of Jamuna TV Salauddin Sumon
expressed his perspectives about women's sports coverage on television. He
said," Men's cricket team or football team get coverage even they do
practice but same does not go for women's team. Basically, women's from any
sports need to do hard work to get the screen. Geopolitical factors Impacts a
lot here. But in 10/15 years women's sports has been getting coverage than
before and I hope Bangladesh can also hope to see the change. Because only
media can shape audience mind."
Sports analyst of Jamuna sports expressed different
angles of this discrimination. "When Bangladesh women's cricket team won
the Asian Cup, they did not get the deserved coverage. Most of the channels
could not make it the lead news for that time. Here marketing policy works so
production house says that put 30 seconds for women's news. Audience do not
love to watch women's sports. So, channels do not want to take risks. Two
factors work here. One is (1) Women's sports is not prosperous. (2) Audience is not interested. So, the ratio
always remains 80:20. When they do not have any important news to cover, they
just use unnecessary contents of men's sports. PV Sindhu, Sania Mirza, Sania
Nehal get coverage because their audience have broad mentality. India is doing
well in women's sports coverage in Asia. But our narrow mentality is stopping
us. It's media's responsibility to change the perception of audience."
Number and duration
Throughout the 15 days analysis, number of male sports
events was 80 and female got the screen for only 10 times. There was 2 mixed
news where the report was made on both male and female athletes. But the
analysis showed there was an exception on 5th October where a whole news was
made on female swimmer. It was a 3-minute report. For the 15 days analysis, the
male sports events coverage was around 2 hours 28 minutes. At the same time
women got 21 minutes screen time.
Scripting
Khelajog program was presented by one presenter. For
men's sports news, the presenter always presented it with great enthusiasm and
spontaneous starting. Even though the news was not significant for giving
coverage on screen, but the presenter presented it in a catchy way. On the
contrary, women's sports coverage does not get such competence and energetic
representation on screen from presenter.
Thematic
In khelajog program, reporter of every news presented
all the fact with full of details for men's sports. Surprisingly, in case of
female athletes there was always lack of information, full of negligence.
Unnecessary contents about male athletes and male sports events make the show
Khelajog more male centric. Voice over, SOT, Voxpop, interview showed
activeness of the show. On the other hand, 10 news of female got dull
representation. In spite of being a good theme, the story did not get good
recognition as the reporter presented it in less important way.
Production quality
In most of the news of female sports, production
quality remained poor. On 25th September's women's football team's coverage,
the channel used only images (poor quality). When they used videography to
cover, high quality if camera was less to be seen unless long news came.
Comparatively, throughout the 15 days analysis it was visible that men athletes
always used to get best production quality from Ekattor TV.
Headline
In Khelajog program, some headlines showed biased
sentence format for male and female sports content. On every news about
Bangladesh men's cricket team, Khelajog used "Bangladesh Cricket
team" while skipping the word Men. But in case of Women's cricket news,
Khelajog used "Women’s Cricket team" always to differentiate the
facts.
Ekattor TV sports journalist put his thoughts on this
matter. He said, "It's not the case that men's sports is getting vast
coverage because Bangladesh or World has more male centric events. Bangladesh
has a lot women centric events which are happening everyday but we are not
covering it. In archery games, male female both are doing good but we barely
know about it. Other countries are working on it and giving equal respect for
women's sports as well. Recently we have seen how Australian cricket board
cancelled the Afghanistan men's tour just because Afghanistan administration do
not want to pursue women's cricket. That's call beauty and respect of games.
But we only focus on men's sporting events. At the same time, we are blaming
audience that they do not want to watch Women's sports news. If media cannot
shape audience perception, then there's no need to cover men's sports as well.
Media smoothly follows audience rather than change their mind."
Number and duration
Unlike two other sports programs of other two
channels, Khelar Somoy had a little coverage of women's sports news Khelar
Somoy reported only 6 news about women's sports which was comparatively very
less from other two channels. For the 15 days analysis, Khelar Somoy covered
total 75 news of male athletes. The duration of male sports news was 2 hour 20
minutes and female sports coverage was 7 minutes. The discrimination was
extremist here.
Scripting
Khelar Somoy presented all facts of men's sports with
highest preference. Presenter presented every news item of men with great
enthusiasm. On 8th October, Bangladesh men's football team lost the match
against Maldives, but the presenter presented it in a defending way.
Unnecessary contents like cricketer Nasir's divorce issue were presented in an
exciting way. On the contrary, 29th September's Bangladesh women's football
team's selection news of the Asia cup, the presentation was not engaging or
inspirational.
Thematic
Khelar Somoy brought out the insignificant contents of
men's sports news mostly. On 3rd October, had one news on "How cricker
Riyad Spend time in free time". 5th October, there again Nasir Hossain
content on the show. Surprisingly, all these news had full of details. On 26th
September, Khelar Somoy reported a news on Afghanistan women's football team
which was a good report because it was an adapted report. On 29th September,
Bangladesh women's football team had a match against Nepal and the report had
no details. From 3rd October to 9th October, Khelar Somoy invited guests to
discuss about different men's sports. Visibly Women's sports news was lack of
coherence and competitiveness.
Production quality
As the analysis showed, Khelar Somoy had only two high
quality news based on women. On the contrary, men's sports news was high
quality based. For most of the news, they used videography (inside the
country). When it came to women's sports news production, one of the news got
high quality production. On 27th September, there was a news based on
Afghanistan women's football team. The report got good quality like men because
it was an adapted report. Surprisingly, on 29th September news on Bangladesh
women's football team's Asia cup selection, the production quality was very
poor. They used video and image both. But the camera was continuously shaking.
Headline
On 26th September’s program there was a news of
Bangladesh men's football team but the headline was written-" National
Football Team". Same thing happened on 28th September's news where they
used -"National Football Team is prepared for SAAF Championship". On
29th September's program, Khelar Somoy repeatedly used national team term. They
never mentioned men's football team to enlighten audience that Bangladesh have
women's football team as well.
Somoy TV sports journalist shared her different
perspective on this issue. "Women’s sports players are extremely neglected
in broadcast media. They do not get the appreciation or promotion from the
sports programs. Women's team did not get vast coverage on media after winning
Asia cup. Male athletes’ facilities, salary are common issues to make a news
but nobody makes news of women athletes’ salary, discrimination. Bangladesh has
33 sports Federations and still women's sports do not get broadcasted. It is a
wrong information that women do not have sports every day. They have but we
don’t make report. But as a fourth
estate of country, media should step back from here and make a drastic change.
Because only media can shape audience mind so there's no point of blaming
audience only. Media should work for it. Reporter, editor, production house
everyone should change their perception for women (Table 2) [19-23].
Table 2: Production house
everyone should change their perception for women.
|
Structure
|
Analysis Elements
|
Observing Units
|
Channels
|
|
Number of News
|
Mentions of male and female athletes by every news
|
Female: 57
|
Ekattor TV,
Jamuna TV, Somoy TV
|
|
Male: 234
|
|
Duration
|
Story time of male and female coverage
|
Female: Minority
|
|
Male: Majority
|
|
Scripting (How the presenter provides the facts)
|
Competence and completeness of news
|
Female: Incomplete and uncompetitive
|
|
Male: Fully complete and highly competitive
|
|
Thematic (How the reporter describes facts)
|
Details, coherent, sentence compile
|
Female: lack of details
|
|
Male: Full of details
|
|
Production quality
|
Visual facts, videography
|
Female: Low quality
|
|
Male: High quality
|
|
Headline
|
Syntax
|
Female: Unenthusiastic & less energetic
|
|
Male: Spontaneous & energetic
|