For the treatment of type 2 diabetes
(T2D), metformin has been the first-line pharmacological agent from most
previous research algorithms [1]. Its characteristic points include efficacy,
safety and also affordability. In addition, clinical application of monotherapy
and/or concomitant usage with other OHAs would be beneficial [2]. However,
recent novel OHAs have changed the situation, including glucagon-like peptide-1
receptor agonists (GLP-1 RA) and sodium-glucose cotransporter-2 inhibitors
(SGLT-2i). Both agents indicate renoprotective and cardioprotective benefits
with various evidence [3]. In comparison with metformin, SGLT-2i showed lower
rate of heart failure (OR 1.51), myocardial infarct (OR 1.45) and similar event
ratio for stroke (OR 1.03) [3]. Then, first-line treatment of metformin for
youth-onset T2D will be suboptimal in more than half patients within 2 years
[4]. From clinical evidence point of view, it may be applicable for changes of
first-line agent for T2D as mentioned above. However, when considering the
actual clinical practice with various factors of cost-effectiveness and
drug-naïve populations of T2D, actual significance of metformin for convenient
management of T2D patients with low CV risk can remain solid in our usual
medical practice [5].
Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare
(MHLW), Japan has continued medical management for long in Japan. Cost
accounting system has conducted according to adding up material cost,
manufacturing expenses, and so on [6]. The principle for deciding each cost for
medical agent consisted from several factors. They include i) manufacturing
(importing) cost such as material cost, personnel expenses, and manufacturing
expenses, ii) sales cost with research cost, etc. iii) operating profit, iv)
distribution cost, and v) consumption tax. Among these process, operating
profit may vary drastically in the broad range of -50% to +100%. It depends on
the degree of the novelty, efficacy or safety in comparison with the existing treatment
so far. The determination method for drug price for the follow-on biologics.
There are principles for two cases as follows: a) case of follow-on products by
biotechnology. The drug price will become 0.7 multiplication of that of the
original product. b) case of chemically synthesized products. The drug price
will be calculated as 0.5 multiplication of that of the original product.
Concerning a) and b), when the medicine is > 10 items 0.6 (for a) or 0.4
(for b) will be multiplied for the calculation [6].
Furthermore, recent topics about drug
pricing of OHA in Japan will be introduced. The first is the pricing of
Metformin. Two kinds of tablets for 250mg and 500mg had different prices until
March 2024. New fiscal year starts in April 2024 in Japan. Both tablets were
decided to have the same cost, which is 10.1 Japanese yen for one tablet of
250mg or 500mg [7]. Its price was set at the minimum level among all medical
agents in Japan (Table 1). Metformin has been prescribed very frequently across
the world. When it is provided 500mg, 1500mg, or 2250mg/day, the drug price
cost would be 10.1, 30.3, 50.5 Japanese Yen (JY) per Tablet. The exchange rate
would be 1 USD= about 150 JY.
Table
1:
Several representative OHAs in topics with pharmacological price in 2024.
|
Type
|
Oral Hypoglycemic Agent
|
yen / 1Tab
|
yen / day
|
remarks
|
|
Biguanide
|
|
|
|
|
|
Metformin (Metgluco) 250mg
|
10.10
|
40.4
|
4 Tab for monotherapy
|
|
Metformin (Metgluco) 500mg
|
10.10
|
20.2
|
2 Tab for monotherapy
|
|
DPP4-i
|
|
|
|
|
|
Vildagliptin (Equa) 25mg
|
60.60
|
121.2
|
2 Tab for monotherapy
|
|
EquMet LD
|
51.00
|
112.0
|
Equa + Met 2 Tab /day
|
|
EquMet HD
|
50.20
|
100.4
|
Equa + Met 4 Tab /day
|
|
Triazine ring
|
|
|
|
|
|
Imeglimin (Twymeeg)
|
34.10
|
136.4
|
4 Tab for monotherapy
|
|
SGLT2-i
|
|
|
|
|
|
Ipragliflozin L-Proline (Suglat) 25mg
|
113.90
|
113.9
|
once in the morning
|
|
Canagliflozin (Canaglu) 100mg
|
158.50
|
158.5
|
”
|
|
empagliflozin (Jardiance) 10mg
|
188.90
|
188.9
|
”
|
|
empagliflozin (Jardiance) 25mg
|
322.60
|
322.6
|
”
|
|
GLP-1RA
|
|
|
|
|
|
Oral semaglutide (Rybelsus) 3mg
|
139.60
|
139.6
|
fasting in the morning
|
|
Oral semaglutide (Rybelsus) 7mg
|
325.70
|
325.7
|
”
|
|
Oral semaglutide (Rybelsus) 14mg
|
488.50
|
488.5
|
”
|
The second is the pricing of combined
OHA of vildaglipitin (Equa) and metformin (Metgluco). The brand names are
Equmet LD (low dose) and EquMet HD (high dose)?[8].
Thus, there are several types of vildagliptin/metformin related agents,which
are Equa, EquMet LD, and Equmet HD [9]. The impressive fact will be presented
in Table 1 [7]. As the contained medical agents increases, the drug price
decreases. Although this policy is rare, certain purpose may exist from
administrative and pharmaceutical law. Monotherapy of metformin and combined
therapy of vildagliptin/metformin have been prevalent with clinical efficacy.
Furthermore, this combination has been known as most economical for patients
and also MJLW of Japanese government [7]. Then, this policy seems to be
beneficial in a broad sense.
The background behind this status can
be observed related to Japan's recent medical policies [10]. In September 2023,
the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare (MHLW) announced national medical
expenses and demographic trends. National medical expenses for fiscal year 2021
(2021.4-2022.3) were 45,035.9 billion yen, an increase of 2,069.4 billion yen
(4.8%) from the previous year. During the same period, the ratio to gross
domestic product (GDP) also gradually increased to 8.18%. According to a study
by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), Japan's
medical expenditure as a percentage of GDP was 25th among OECD member countries
in the 2011 report, which was below the average. However, it rose to the 4th
rank in the 2023 report in OECD countries, which seems to keep higher standard
level at present. Regarding the population, the total fertility rate decreased
from 1.30 in the previous year to 1.26, the lowest on record (2022.1-2022.12)
[11].
Given the current state of medical
administration, MHLW is concerned about the present situation where total
medical expenses are rapidly increasing every year [11]. As one of the
countermeasures, MHLW continued the policy of using generic medicine more frequently
than brand-name medicine and controlling drug costs in medical expenses. Among
these, two types of OHA are combined as a combination drug, and the drug price
is set lower than the combined drug price of the two OHAs. These trends are
expected to continue in the future. As our prediction in medical area, there
will be strong points and weak points. However, at least in part, it can also
be considered a beneficial direction from the patient's perspective.
In conclusion, latest topics
concerning OHA and drug pricing were described. Metformin with a dose-dependent
hypoglycemic effect can be easily increased in dose, where improving HbA1c will
be expected associated with great economic benefits. Several kinds of combined
OHA were used in clinical practice. This trend may come from the policy of
MHLW, and will be continued thereafter. Drug pricing will be changed annually.
It is expected that this article will become a useful reference in future
practice.
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of
interest.
Funding
There was no funding received for this paper.